As a lover of all things Halloween, I take any excuse to bake a spooky treat! Luckily, when my boyfriend and I started dating, I got myself another excuse: his birthday is October 17th!
I am home for fall break, so this was our best chance to celebrate, even though it’s a little early. I knew I wanted something fall flavored, not just a classic chocolate or vanilla. I also am well aware of my boyfriends favorite flavor: coffee! He is one of those people that orders extra shots of espresso not for the caffeine, but the flavor. So what is a fall-flavored cake that would go well with coffee? Well, that’s an easy one!
I intentionally asked him a few weeks earlier if he liked pumpkin spice lattes. He replied emphatically that of course he did, they’re coffee and pumpkin! Have I mentioned that he loves Halloween as much as I do? Anything seasonally themed around October is perfect for him.
Well, the answer was obvious! I knew I wanted to do some fancy decorations, so I wanted the cake to be pretty simple. A doctored-up spice cake mix would work perfectly with the addition of some sour cream, extra flavorings, and lots of instant coffee! By adding more ingredients, I can turn a two-layer cake mix into a three-layer cake, which makes it even more of a spectacle.
I’d recently seen a Halloween cake with meringue bones around the sides, and I loved the way it looked! I did not feel like baking a meringue, so I decided piping some white chocolate was the best option. I can do it while the cake is baking and just leave them in the fridge until I’m ready to decorate!
Soon, everything came together. I presented it to him, and he was completely thrilled. When we took a bite, I realized this may just be the moistest cake I’ve ever made. With canned pumpkin, sour cream, melted butter, and a creamy frosting, it literally melts in your mouth! However, it is NOT too sweet! The coffee counters it perfectly. It is also very light and fluffy; my mother compared it to a really light pumpkin quick bread.
Overall, this cake is a winner for October birthdays, a Halloween dessert, or a show-stopping Thanksgiving finale if you’re not into pie. It’s impressive enough for any dinner party. Enjoy!
INGREDIENTS:
- 1 spice cake mix
- 2/3 cup sugar
- 4 eggs
- 1/3 cup melted butter
- 1/4 cup water
- 1/3 cup sour cream
- 1 15oz can pumpkin
- 1/4 cup instant coffee (if you use instant espresso, which is fine, use less. Just taste the batter until you like the coffee flavor.)
- 6 cups white frosting (homemade or canned- I dyed mine orange)
For the garnishes: pumpkin mallows, black decorator frosting, sprinkles, white candy melts, Halloween cookie cutters.
TO PREPARE:
Preheat the oven to 350, and prepare three 9 inch round cake pans (I do spray, parchment paper, and more spray. It NEVER sticks).
Combine all the cake ingredients (everything but the frosting and garnishes) in a large bowl and whisk until everything is incorporated. Scoop evenly into the three pans (I use a cup measure, alternating between each pan to keep it even).
Bake for 25 minutes or until firm on top and the sides pull away from the pan. Don’t do the toothpick test; this cake is naturally very moist and will probably leave a soft crumb on the pick, and you do NOT want to over bake it because a tooth pick wasn’t clean.
If you want to decorate it like me, backtrack a bit. While the cake was baking, melt some white candy melts in the microwave. Four big blocks did it for me, in the microwave for 1 minute and 15 seconds, followed by some vigorous stirring. Get a ziplock bag and open it, then place it into a large cup, with the edges pulled over the sides to get a good aim at the inside of the bag. Pour in the chocolate!
Get a sheet of parchment paper onto a baking sheet, and spray it. Place some Halloween cookie cutters on the paper. Snip the end on the ziplock bag, and pipe into the cookie cutters, filling each shape completely. Allow to sit for about 2 minutes, then remove the cookie cutters. The shapes may spread some, but that’s okay! We don’t need perfection here! Apply sprinkles, candy eyes, etc, until they look just how you like. Pop the baking sheet into the fridge and let them chill and set.
Once the cakes are cool, get your white frosting ready and dye it orange, if desired. Frost each layer of the cake, and down the sides! For the top, I used cookie cutters again as stencils to create the black cat, then I free-handed the Jack O’ Lantern face with black gel frosting. Then, decorate with some mallow pumpkins and sprinkles. To finish, get out the white candy melt garnishes and stick them to the sides. I didn’t need any additional frosting, but if you only did a thin layer, you may.
Tah Dah! Trick or Treat!